Sunday, May 6, 2007

The Cruelest Abuse

¡Hola! Everybody...
Yes, I do actually think feminism is for everybody, not just for women. Enjoy the start of a new work week, people.

* * *

-=[ Punishment ]=-

This is gonna hurt me more than you


How many of us heard those words while growing up? I know I heard it many times. I wasn’t a bad child in the sense that I got into trouble. I was more a “questioner” – I had to have a “why.” My mother was old school, asking for a reason was equivalent to disrespect, and so her response was usually, Because I said so,” or, if I pressed too hard, a smack, a chancletazo*, in some cases a “whoopin’,” or a genuine beat down. Like the time I managed to create a swimming pool out of our tenement apartment bathroom. That was a crime deserving of a beat down.

I wasn’t bad, just creative. LOL!

Many of us remember getting beat downs and whoopins. My mother actually made us fetch the belt and make us smell it as a warning. Then people wonder why today I like the smell of leather and spanking women’s behinds, LOL. Most of my young life was spent in power struggles with my mother. I would take her physical punishment, but all it did was make me want to do more of whatever it was I was being punished for.

When I was a boy, my father never touched me, he spoke to me, respected me, and inspired me to create higher standards for myself. If my father asked me to do something, I did it happily. My mother, on the other hand, had to hit me constantly. Her favorite form of punishment? Smacking my face. To this day, I have issues with anyone touching my face. To this day I sometimes still reflexively flinch from a lover's caress.

Some parents, and this is especially true in communities of color, argue that newer forms of discipline, like “time outs” don’t work. They argue that the old tradition, derived from the Biblical dogma of spare the rod, spoil the child, offered an effective physical discipline, that when done correctly will only have to be enforced a few times. The adherents of physical discipline often point out that all they need is to give a look.

Others, and I happen to be one of them, respond that the punishment methods used by our parents were created out of anger and based on religious dogma, personal frustration, and a lack of respect for children as people. I also differentiate between punishment and discipline -- the two are not the same.

Who’s right?

He who spareth the rod, hateth his son: but he who loveth him correcteth him betimes.”

-- Proverbs 13:24


Some Bible readers argue that this adage has been taken out of context -- that it was not originally intended as advocating physical punishment. Whatever the case may be this is the way it’s been commonly understood. Today, I argue from the vantage point of a minority since there’s a plurality in America that disagrees with my stance. So it makes sense to explore whether this statement makes any sense.

There are very few instances of absolutes in the study of human behavior. However, even a cursory glance at the literature suggests that no other “common sense” saying has done so much harm to so many people. I can’t think of any other proverb that’s founded on so ignorant an understanding of human development.

Does physical punishment “teach the kid a lesson”? Absolutely. It teaches that “the way to solve problems is to beat up others,” as one researcher put it. Now am aware that there different degrees of punishment, not all “rods” are the same. There’s a big difference between a light tapping on a child’s behind and the sort of punishment that causes bruising (what’s that you say: you have caused your child to bruise? That’s abuse and don’t let me catch you doing it!). However studies spanning over fifty years by many different people have clearly demonstrated that slapping, spanking, or otherwise using violence on children is never necessary and always potentially harmful.

Studies going back as far as the 1950s and 1960s show conclusively that physical (corporal) punishment produces children who are more, not less, aggressive than their peers. A study conducted in 1960 studied 875 eight year-olds and found a clear-cut relationship between the severity of the physical punishment they received and how aggressive their peers judged them to be. Twenty two years later, the researchers tracked down some of the same subjects and found that many of the aggressive children had grown into aggressive adults. Even more disturbing, many of them were now using physical punishment on their own children.

Of course, you’re probably saying that you turned out fine and that your children seem to be okay. Growing up in an abusive household doesn’t guarantee that one will eventually become an abuser. Still, even so-called “acceptable” levels of physical punishment can result in perpetuating violence and unhappiness. Research continues to find:

A large survey revealed that people who had been punished most severely as teenagers were four times more likely to beat their spouses than people whose parents had never hit them at all.

Another study found that alcoholics and people suffering from depression were much more likely than other individuals to have been physically punished when they were children.

A more recent study found that three to five year-olds who were spanked by their parents were more likely than other children to be aggressive while playing at a day care center. Watching violent TV programs and playing with toys such as toy guns was also found to be related to aggression, but not as strongly as physical punishment was.

Apart for the long-term damage it may cause, physical punishment is simply ineffective. It may suppress the misbehavior (or what the parents deems misbehavior) in the short run, but ultimately it promotes little more than a determination to avoid getting caught. The most effective way to raise children who respect others is to respect and care for them, to explain what they’ve done wrong and why it’s wrong, and to work with them in creating solutions to the problems.

I have a colleague who’s at her wits end as to why her 4 year-old daughter has been kicked out of two day care centers and pre-school. My colleague is only now beginning to listen to what I’ve been telling her for years -- that she needs to stop using physical force as a way to raise her daughter.

My brother once called me in the middle of the night. I had sent my son to Florida to stay with him for summer vacation and he calls and says, “Yo, I gotta tell you something. I’m here at Blockbusters with your son, and I told him that he could watch any movie he wanted to watch. I even took him by the porn section.”

By now, I’m fuming.

My brother went on, “Anyway, even though I told him he could watch whatever he wanted and I would never tell you, he said he couldn’t do it because his father trusts him and he wouldn’t want to do anything to mess that up. You got a good kid, Eddie,” and he hung up.

To me, that was the greatest thing. My son had internalized positive values, which meant that he would behave in accordance with certain values and principles even when I wasn’t around to punish him. I didn’t teach this to my son through coercion, or threats of physical pain. This was done through a long and painful process of mutual discovery, modeling behavior, and actually teaching my son critical thinking skills (and fuck you if you tell your kid not to smoke pot, but you smoke like a champ!).

This is not so for children raised on a diet of fear and violence. In fact, it could be that hitting children makes things worse even for toddlers. As reported in the journal Developmental Psychology, “infants of physically punishing mothers showed the lowest levels of compliance and were most likely to manipulate breakable objects.” An earlier study of more than 800 toddlers and their mothers discovered that “the more frequent the punishment for the child” -- especially physical punishment and especially administered by the mother -- “the more severe were all the behavior problem syndromes studied in the child.” Even if the punishment didn’t cause these behavior problems, it damn sure didn’t eliminate them.

Not too long ago, I watched as a mother of two young children hit one child for hitting the other. Great! It’s true that a huge number of Americans choose this way of dealing with a child who deliberately hurts someone else. Apparently, it’s “common sense” to believe that the best way to teach that hurting is wrong is by hurting. Despite of the overwhelming research showing just how harmful and ineffective physical punishment is, an overwhelming majority of Americans still resort to using physical punishment.

Why? Well, one reason I hear a lot is that real harm is caused by child abuse -- what those other people do – not by “normal” spanking. Perhaps they lack self-control to deal with their children more positively and productively. Perhaps, they have themselves been raised this way and see nothing wrong with it, and rather than confront the implications of what was done to them at a tender age, prefer to treat their children the same way. Whatever the reason, be clear that we live in a different world today. Children have a heightened awareness of the consequences for punishing the “old fashioned way” and with access to 1-800 numbers and cell phones, hitting your kid just might be more painful to you.

Love,

Eddie

Resources

Miller, A. (1990). For your own good: Hidden cruelty in child-rearing and the roots of violence (3rd ed.). New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux. (click here)

Gilligan, J. (2003). Shame, guilt, and violence. Social Research: An International Quarterly of Social Sciences, 4(70), 1149-1180. (click here)

Thursday, March 22, 2007

The Friday Sex Blog [Wilhelm Reich]

Hola Everybody,
No one volunteered to be featured in this week’s sex blog.So I had to ask Paris to come to the rescue!

* * *

-=[ Wilhelm Reich and the Function of Orgasm]=-


I first became familiar with Wilhelm Reich’s work when I was an undergraduate and beginning my explorations into the synthesis of psychology and Buddhist meditation. That’s when I discovered the concept of body armor. According to Reich, personality development could be compared to a form of body armor -- actual physical hardening of parts of the body as a way to stop an individual from understanding their neurosis. In other words, we create a physical armor in response to emotions and trauma that stop us from feeling fully.

I liked that idea because I would confront it in my meditation practice. I had a lot of “denseness” in certain parts of my body, especially in the area around my chest. But I’m getting off topic.

Wilhelm Reich has to be one the most interesting figures in early psychology. I’m surprised no one has bothered doing a film on his life. He certainly was a controversial figure and eventually would die tragically.

He was a follower of Freud but early on he moved away from psychoanalysis and started to evolve his own ideas about the relationship between mind and body. In The Function of Orgasm, Reich came up with the idea that the potential to experience complete, uninhibited orgasm was vital to the healthy adult. In Reich’s view, failure to release pent-up sexual energy resulted in deep-seated psychological problems (neuroses). This may not sound earth-shattering by today’s standards, but in his time, this was almost blasphemous.

Reich also developed the idea, which has been somewhat validated by modern science, of physiological anchoring. In simple terms, physiological anchoring is the notion that psychological experiences lead to a direct physical change of an organ in the human body. In this way, our psychology creates a matrix of permanently tensed or paralyzed muscles, and emotions work as a form of character armor, which is apparently purely physical (this is where I got my idea for “squeaky vaginas” btw *grin*).

Reich believed that it was possible to relieve mental problems by directly manipulating and massaging the body. This therapeutic intervention, known as orgasm therapy, supposedly dismantled the body armoring and therefore liberated the nervous system to experience full and satisfying orgasm, which Reich identified as the key to mental health.

Early during his career, Reich had grown increasingly involved in sexual liberation movements, which ultimately led to his split from the dominant psychoanalytic movement of the time. His ideas also became increasing unconventional but still interesting, at least to me. I believe Reich was looking at conceptual maps unknown to the psychological schools of his day. For example, he claimed that he had measured a previously unknown energy that was discharged by the pelvis during orgasm. He named this energy orgone energy, claiming that it moved in spirals and was blue. For Reich this was the essence of life itself -- the cosmic energy that permeated all beings, as well as the answer to all religious and philosophical problems.

His work reminds me of the chakra system and also the conception of Astral Light, an all-pervading energy field. It’s interesting to note that today there’s a lot of speculation around Field theory that is a more sophisticated explanation of what Reich was attempting to explore.

Eventually, his work became increasingly less conventional. He built orgone accumulation boxes where he claimed he could store orgasmic energy. He sat patients in the boxes in order to cure them of colds, arthritis, and other disorders, including cancer. When he began distributing his orgone boxes as cures for cancer he attracted the adverse attention of the FDA. Eventually he would die in prison, on a charge of contempt of court.

While many would argue that Reich’s ideas became mad and worthless, there is little agreement over exactly when.

Love,

Eddie



Headlines

[un]Common Sense